Why does Grocery Store Outlet charge EBT users for bags when nobody else does?

By CORY ELIA

editor’s note: After a lot of research and conversations, we found out that Grocery Outlet was within their legal rights to charge EBT users for bags.

As a college student and journalist I’m not the most financially well off. Luckily, a new program started late in 2019 that allows low-income college students the ability to get food stamps and provide a bit of financial relief.

I had EBT benefits years ago but after enrolling in college lost them. When I heard about the new program I instantly applied. It’s helped me immensely to be able to keep a couple of hundred dollars in my budget monthly.

KOIN reports: “Oregon’s plastic bag ban takes effect in 2020

The other day I went into my local Grocery Outlet on 122nd and Division to make a few purchases for my evening’s meal on my EBT card. When it came to the new paper bag tax I had been told that EBT card purchases were exempt from it.

Even though I had been told this I usually have my backpack with me and never really purchase more than a few items. I just put the few items I have in my bag after purchase and head home. I do this to completely avoid using any paper bags altogether. 

However, on this night I needed more than a few items and had over ten blocks to skateboard home. So I inevitably needed a bag to get my stuff home. After being rung up by the cashier she asked me if I need a bag quite politely. When I answered yes she proceeded to state “We charge ten cents cash per paper bag, is that okay?” 

This piqued my interest because I was told about the exemption. I replied to her “it would be if that wasn’t against the new law”. Confused, she paused and asked her night manager to come over. He proceeded to explain to me that it’s what the owner of the store set as a rule. I told to him “the law says EBT purchases are exempt from the paper bag tax”.

He asked what I wanted to do.

Because I had no cash on me at the time, my solution was to load my backpack to the brim and carry the last few items home home by hand. Yes, I looked like that popular meme going around with the people holding all their groceries which says “Portland grocery shoppers be like”. 

Prior to doing this though I had handed the night managers one of my business cards and asked him to have the owner call me. I have also since found the name and email address of the owner and emailed him.

I’ve gone in several mornings and directly asked for the owner and always get told: “he’s not here and we can’t just call him”.

Well, that’s where being a journalist and researcher comes in handy. After this, I decided to go digging and see what I could find out on the new paper bag tax. 

HB 2509 was passed by Oregon’s legislator in 2019 and prohibits stores and restaurants from providing single-use checkout bags to customers. However, there is an exemptions section for HB 2509. Provided below is the exemption section of that bill. There are in fact a number of different exceptions where the paper bag tax is not applicable.

Out of interest I went to all the other major stores in the area and made similar purchases which I needed and asked for a bag. Every time I put it on my EBT card they never charged me for the bag. Neither WinCo, Fred Meyers, or Walmart charge EBT users for bags.

Village Portland reached out via email to the management of Grocery Outlet about the law, below is their response.

The management’s response, “moving forward if you feel this to be an issue you are free to request an empty box at time of check out” is insulting and the fact of how much paper is used in the box compared to the bag is also confusing because Portland is striving to use less paper products. They also seem to be misinterpreting the bill. Their attachments were the same as the exception section from above.

I responded: “Okay, obviously you are not legally understand the tax bill and its exceptions. I have had a lawyer look at this all and indeed they say that you are in violation of the law. So at this juncture I have to ask exactly what you are using the $0.10 cash for.”

In the hopes of having a full understanding of the exceptions for the bill and if this local grocery store was actually in compliance, Village Portland reached out to the Oregon Attorney General’s office via email but has yet to get a reply.

After talking to our attorney, it appears Grocery Outlet is correct in this matter. It also appears that the exception is by choice of the grocery store. If a store feels the extra bag charge is an undo burden on already low-income individuals they can forgo charging them. My takeaway from this is to not shop at Grocery Outlet— I’m not going to shop there anymore— because they don’t appreciate their customers.

***

Cory Elia is a journalist, photographer, videographer, documentary director & producer, radio personality & podcaster. His journalistic focus is on politics, protest, and poverty.

Contact Cory:

Facebook: Cory Elia
Twitter: @therealcoryelia

This weekend

Journalist and educator Lisa Loving and I definitely share a passion for community reporting and the need to help shape how media and reporting is evolving.

She asked me to speak about my work at a signing for her new book: “Street Journalist: Understand and Report the News in Your Community” this week.

I am thankful for her input on the work we’re doing, the opportunity to speak, and the entire evening’s discussion.

Ask for Loving’s book at your local bookstore, or purchase it online at Powell’s.

SATURDAY, OCTOBER 28TH

Learn more about the Johnson Creek Floodplain (event):

“Join us for a free, family-friendly event to learn more about the Johnson Creek floodplain and how to protect your family from flooding. Enjoy games, crafts, and raffle prizes. Grab a donut, coffee, or hot chocolate on us!

Representatives from Reed College, the Wharton School of Risk Management, Hagan Hamilton Insurance, and City of Portland Environmental Services will be available… “

Zenger Farm, 11741 SE Foster Rd * 9 am – 11 am

***

Lents Community Harvest Festival:

At this, the 16th annual festival, there’s be crafts, games, door prizes, and a quilt raffle!

Pilgrim Lutheran Church, 4244 SE 91st Ave * 1 pm – 4 pm

This weekend

Portland neighbors put a lot of work into their neighborhood associations, but after a considerable time with a front-row seat at several, the institution always seems to attract conflict. Is this just the nature of humanity, or trying around geography? You’d think common ground was a good place to start.

While the conversation has been around how to bring new groups to the table, I’ve been wondering how we could fix the current system. Reform to the grievance system and more support and training to help board members encourage engagement are my first ideas…

If you have ideas, I’d like to hear them, and will be starting a story soon to bring more ideas forward. Thanks for reading and being involved as we work together to improve civic engagement.

***

This is the second of a five-episode series that played on Open Signal earlier this year. The series is a compilation of Village Portland videos that feature Portlanders organizing events and serving their community.

In this episode, we feature the annual Halloween party at Burnside Skatepark; the Portland Krampus Walk; a performance at a MLK celebration; a visit to the Grotto for their Christmas choir concerts; an interview with the designer of the Cascadian flag; and a look at the City of Portland’s Sunday Parkways.

HALLOWEEN FUN

Haunted Ghost Town (event):

This weekend and next weekend as well…

‘“Where History Won’t Die’, Portland’s newest haunted attraction!” 

Rossi Farms, 3839 NE 122nd Ave * adult $12, youth $8 * 7 pm – 9:30 pm

Village Portland update!

Hello everyone! It’s Andrew here, I just wanted to say hello and update you on what Village Portland has been up to.

We’ve added new neighborhoods, partnerships, and reporters— and we are stoked about some new moves in the works.

Cory Elia (Reflection: conducting the survey for the Portland Street Response) and Lesley McLam have been doing some awesome work around homelessness and homeless organizing, and are focusing in on more focused reporting on the areas of PSU and St Johns, respectively.

McLam has been reporting on Jason Barns Landing, a managed camp in North Portland that’s taking what I see as a civil disobedience approach to their camp. And their answering the question: what happens when homeless folk tire of being moved— tired of having their community scattered— keep coming back to the same place?

Both Elia and McLam are volunteers at community radio station KBOO, and use their equipment to publish a podcast called TRIP-P. Like KBOO, Open Signal, is a resource for community media creators that we’ve been collaborating with.

Another media non-profit that trains homeless youth in video storytelling we’re collaborating with, Outside the Frame, also uses Open Signal equipment.

Here’s the third episode of Village Portland Presents, a five-episode series we produced for Open Signal earlier this year. It’s a compilation of video stories, themed around community organizing and culture.

It’s been great to meet other organizations and folks passionate about independent media, and offering more folks a chance to tell their stories.

Here’s our take on the 82nd Avenue Parade of Roses for 2019

It rained really hard earlier that morning, but when it was time for the parade to roll, the 82nd Avenue of Roses Parade was blessed with dry and sometimes sunny weather… typical spring in the Willamette Valley.

82nd Avenue is the highway that binds together multiple neighborhoods in East Portland— including Powellhurst-Gilbert. And the groups that march proudly are just a tiny fraction of those that make East Portland a great place to live.

I hope you enjoy all the people and smiles that made the parade so enjoyable (and tolerate our zany commentary). We hope it encourages you to find your own way to get involved.